We had a 3/4 day charter and tried for sailfish. But none were found. Boated three small black tuna and missed a couple of others. Captain Randy was awesome and tried hard all day to find a sailfish. He was very friendly and made sure my group of young people were looked after. First mate David was terrific and worked tirelessly to hook up fish. He was also very friendly and good to be around. The boat was in good condition and the right size for our group. Two big motors purred all day. The boat was set up well for fishing.

I highly recommend this crew to anyone visiting Costa Rica! A very knowledgeable captain and a hard working first mate kept me on the fish all day. We landed 7 bull mahi, 5 yellowfin tuna, and a black marlin! It was non stop action and the crew is very friendly, humorous, and speaks English. With this crew you will ask yourself if you’re going fishing or catching! At the end of the trip they prepared our tuna with mango, avocado, spices, and soy sauce before our trip back to shore. I will be coming back next year for sure!

“Reza: Fishing Herradura surpassed all expectations! Captain Randy’s expertise and David’s outstanding service made it the best fishing trip ever.

Chuck: Unforgettable adventure at Fishing Herradura! Captain Randy’s knowledge of the waters and David’s impeccable attention to detail created an unparalleled experience.

Sam: A must-try! Fishing Herradura, guided by Captain Randy, offers top-notch fishing. Hat’s off to David for making our trip truly memorable. Best experience ever!”

See you guys on the next trip

Capt. Randy and David where fabulous on our full day off shore trip. Boat was clean and comfortable. With good tunes and tasty snacks. The mahi were really active and we caught all we could handle.  Managed to catch and release a small sailfish also. David did a great job cleaning and bagging a bunch of mahi fillets for us to enjoy in CR and take home. It always helps when the this fish are biting, but this is one of the better trips we have had in many years of fishing.  Thanks guys, hope to get back to CR again soon!

Fished full day offshore with Capt. Randy and mate, David.  Randy gave us several options based on time of year and recent reports.  We opted to troll and caught mahi all day.  Was not our day for billfish, but guys worked hard and stayed extra time trying.  We felt included in the process of catching fish instead of just being handed a rod with a hooked fish.  Fishing with these guys felt like fishing with longtime friends.  Lots of laughs and smiles all day.  Thanks guys for a great day on the water!